top of page
Search

Getting to WITH as a School Leader

13 minutes ago
4 min read

Using the Social Discipline Window and Relationship Matrix to Frame Your Role

By Jessica Villeneuve


If you've ever felt that leading a school means carrying everything alone, or that your good ideas stall once they reach the classroom, you're not imagining it. School leaders are asked to do so much: hold high expectations, respond to growing student needs, support overextended staff, and keep a shared vision alive, often with little time and few people with whom to think it through. Leadership is isolating, and when the pressure rises, it's tempting to operate by directing from the top or stepping back to avoid conflict.


Neither approach builds the trust that schools depend on. When staff feel unheard or unsupported, that disconnection doesn't stay in the staff room. It shows up in how adults respond to students and in whether classrooms feel safe and connected. Operating from the WITH quadrant (see below) gives leaders a practical framework and a place to practice leading with their communities, so that accountability and support grow together.


What does a truly regulated, calm school feel like? Learn how the RRP model empowers students, supports teachers, and builds lasting resilience in grades 7-12.

What does it look or sound like from each quadrant?


NOT

When both our expectations and support are low, we are more likely to be in the “not” quadrant. Being in that quadrant for me as a classroom teacher looked like showing a lot of movies, having students grade each other’s papers, calling in sick. As a parent, it might sound like ignoring phone calls and emails about your child’s progress at school. As a school leader, the easy example is not responding to emails, but more likely scenarios could be referring staff to the handbook rather than hearing their concerns or backing up one staff person or a parent, without hearing both sides.


FOR

When our love, concern, and support are high, but our expectations and boundaries are low, we function from the FOR quadrant. From my experience, the majority of educators including classroom teachers and support staff, find themselves here. As a parent, I default to FOR here, as well. It’s easier to pick up my kids’ strewn clothing and discarded yogurt cups than to wait for them to come home so that we can work on household expectations and being a good “roommate” together later in the day.


In schools, this could be a teacher with their own contractual duties also saying yes to additional tasks and work, such as committees, events, bulletin boards, extracurricular activities, especially when these are not giving lift or joy to that individual. A concrete example from my own experience as an administrator was my doing “Test to Stay” duties during the COVID pandemic to keep these “off the nurses’ plates” I felt my job was to run interference for them given they had enough to do with so many complicated health issues to address at the time. I missed the chance to plan with them and to honor their training, skills, and capacity.


TO

Many educational leaders default to this orientation under stress. We can only manage and delegate so many things. Having experience and competence can make giving out instructions and tasks feel efficient, saving time and energy. Starting sentences with “You will…” “I need you to…” isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but there are ways to distribute leadership and tasks in a more collaborative way that will build more effectiveness and trust across your team. What leaders miss when stuck in the TO quadrant is an attention to high expectations without the support needed to succeed. Interactions become power-based, transactional and performative leaving out the human element of the work.


WITH

Getting to WITH is a process that takes thoughtfulness and intentionality to accomplish. When you reflect on your practices, consider asking yourself: “Am I operating from a place of high expectations and high care? Where can I have more of both?” This can then be applied to everything you do, from the way you facilitate meetings and make decisions to how you respond to and manage conflict.


Ideas for shifting to WITH


In Meetings:

  • Teams can share responsibility for creating agendas and setting priorities

  • Include time in agendas to slow down, regulate, connect, and check in before attending to business. (The time spent doing these creates spaciousness and ease, which in the end saves time. When the people present are seen, heard, regulated and connected, task completion is more pleasurable and focused.)


During Decision Making (ask yourself questions like):

  • Is there an opportunity here for me to consider other voices or stakeholders?

  • Am I missing something important? Would it be helpful to gather more information?

  • Do I know enough about the situation to decide on this myself?

  • Can I check in with those who may be impacted to learn more about that potential impact?


All of these may lead to less isolation for you as a leader and a chance to make fewer decisions on your own. This builds trust, reduces your burden, and results in decisions that work better for everyone, ultimately leading to fewer complications and more decision-making down the road. Consider a coaching cycle to support you in this work! Learn more about Jessica’s coaching approach here.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page